Jump to content

Semi auto question (just comfirming what a guy said)


Wrighty112
 Share

Recommended Posts

Ive been in the army cadets and the TA to so I'm not a novice to shooting, however i'm new to shotguns so just little confussed. When a catridge discharges the gas enters the gas parts into the gas cilinder and forces the piston to recoil the bolt... Removing the spent catridge an reloading a fresh one.

 

That's all fair an well but a mate said that shotguns also use the force from the carriage to force the bolt back once released from the barrel (if u get my meaning)

 

Is this true?:oops: If So it could answer a few questions.

 

Cheers in advance

 

:-)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Beretta (as well as many other makers) - gas operated like you say.

Benelli - recoil operated, the advantage being less cleaning needed.

 

 

Ive been in the army cadets and the TA to so I'm not a novice to shooting, however i'm new to shotguns so just little confussed. When a catridge discharges the gas enters the gas parts into the gas cilinder and forces the piston to recoil the bolt... Removing the spent catridge an reloading a fresh one.

 

That's all fair an well but a mate said that shotguns also use the force from the carriage to force the bolt back once released from the barrel (if u get my meaning)

 

Is this true?:oops: If So it could answer a few questions.

 

Cheers in advance

 

:-)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes thats it in a nutshell there are inertia recoil and gas operated my Beretta 302 is gas operated

I have used the old type Browning A5 recoil where the barrel moved back during the shot and

which I wasn't happy with, I believe Franchi still use that

system. Benelli use the inertia system which is explained here well enough to confuse me. :oops:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes thats it in a nutshell there are inertia recoil and gas operated my Beretta 302 is gas operated

I have used the old type Browning A5 recoil where the barrel moved back during the shot and

which I wasn't happy with, I believe Franchi still use that

system. Benelli use the inertia system which is explained here well enough to confuse me. :yes:

 

 

delbert,

 

Just curious, but what didn't you like about the long recoil action that made you get rid of it?

 

Yes, the Franchi 48 AL, browning A5, and Remington 48 all use the same long recoil style action. There are a few other guns that do, but you won't see them in this country. The benelli's and their progeny use the inertia recoil system which is effectively the same (the recoil of the cartridge moves the bolt backwards against a spring which closes the action after the cartridge is ejected). The difference is that the Benelli uses a small, stiff spring inside the bolt while the long recoil guns have a big, softer spring on the mag tube.

 

Thanks

Rick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cheers guys... Do some guns use both gas an inertia system??

 

 

As already said, its one or the other, I've never come accross a mixed system...who knows, but it would be interesting ;)

 

I favour the Benelli recoil system from a cleaning point of view, but for usage I prefer the gas system.

 

So perhaps if someone can invent a gas system that stays as clean as the recoil system they would be on a winner...Beretta keep trying but have a long way to go yet! :good::hmm::yes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As already said, its one or the other, I've never come accross a mixed system...who knows, but it would be interesting :good:

 

I favour the Benelli recoil system from a cleaning point of view, but for usage I prefer the gas system.

 

So perhaps if someone can invent a gas system that stays as clean as the recoil system they would be on a winner...Beretta keep trying but have a long way to go yet! :mad::hmm::yes:

 

I have two semis the winchester and the beretta urika 2 and believe me the winchester is the one living in the cabinet,compared to the beretta cleaning the winny is a chore,all the heavy fouling in the beretta is dealt with with the spinning piston,the rest is a doddle ,cleaned in half the time and i choose gas as you get less recoil bit more dirt more stable gun for second shot,in my humble opinion BM :yes:;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

delbert,

 

Just curious, but what didn't you like about the long recoil action that made you get rid of it?

 

Yes, the Franchi 48 AL, browning A5, and Remington 48 all use the same long recoil style action. There are a few other guns that do, but you won't see them in this country. The benelli's and their progeny use the inertia recoil system which is effectively the same (the recoil of the cartridge moves the bolt backwards against a spring which closes the action after the cartridge is ejected). The difference is that the Benelli uses a small, stiff spring inside the bolt while the long recoil guns have a big, softer spring on the mag tube.

 

Thanks

Rick

Previously I'd shot with a Remington gas operated by comparison I found the Browning rough to shoot and the barrel motion distracting I was offered the A5 at a very very decent price (ex MOD) but even so it was not a gun I'd be comfortable with so I passed on it. I didn't buy my Beretta till years later and I'm still very happy with it

Link to comment
Share on other sites

cheers for the replys, reason i was asking is that i have had problems with my baikal getting stoppages, and the dealer said it was how i was holding and telling me it uses inertia to recoil even though it has a gas recoil system, so took it back again and finially it had stoppages when he tested and an then told me the ejectors faulty... now getting it repaired for free :-)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...